The last witness has stepped down. The adjudicator looks up from the notes and says, "Your submissions, please." From here, oral argument in court usually runs in this order: you open, you take questions, you listen to the other side, and if you are given a reply, you get the last word.

Most advice on argument stops at the opening. This piece follows one invented submission from its first sentence to the last word of reply, so you can see what each stage does and where licensees tend to lose the thread. If you have not yet built the finding you are arguing for, start with our piece on what makes legal argument persuasive. This one picks up the moment you stand.

The Hypothetical And The Finding It Needs

This is a hypothetical, invented for teaching. No real file, client, tribunal or result sits behind it.

At a regulatory hearing, a business faces an allegation that it exceeded a sound limit. Under the invented rule in this scenario, the reading must be taken at the complainant's property line. Nobody disputes the number on the meter. The only issue is where the meter stood. The inspector's notes say "laneway, rear". In cross-examination he agreed he never measured from the property line, and a photograph entered as Exhibit 3 shows his tripod beside the business's rear door. You act for the business, and the adjudicator has asked you to go first.

The finding you need is narrow: the reading was taken at the rear door, not at the property line. Everything below serves that one finding.

The Opening: One Request In Thirty Seconds

The opening tells the adjudicator what you want and why they can give it to you. Thirty seconds is a discipline, not a rule of court. In the hypothetical it might sound like this:

There is one question on this hearing: where the meter stood. We accept the reading. We say it was not taken where the rule requires. The inspector's own notes put him in the laneway at the rear, he agreed he never measured from the property line, and Exhibit 3 shows his tripod beside the rear door. We ask you to find that the reading was not taken at the property line. I will take you to those three pieces of evidence in that order.

Four moves in six sentences. It names the issue, concedes what is not in dispute, states the requested finding in words the adjudicator could copy into reasons, and promises a route. The concession matters. Accepting the reading tells the bench you are not fighting everything, which makes the one thing you are fighting easier to hear.

The Roadmap And Where The Record Says It

A roadmap is a promise, so keep it. You said three pieces of evidence in that order. Deliver them in that order, and say where each one is.

For each point, give the reference before the argument: the page of the notes, the passage of the transcript, the exhibit number. Then wait. An adjudicator who is still finding the page is not listening to you, and a submission delivered over the sound of pages turning is lost. Once they are there, read the line, say what it proves, and tie it to the finding.

Say each point once. Under pressure, licensees tend to repeat the strongest point at the end of every section. The adjudicator heard it the first time, and the repetition spends time you will want for questions.

When The Bench Asks: Answer, Concede, Return

Questions are where oral submissions are won or lost, and they rarely arrive in the order you planned. In the hypothetical, the adjudicator interrupts your second point:

Adjudicator: The rear door is right beside the neighbour's yard. Isn't a reading there a fair measure of what the neighbour heard?

You: Not under this rule. It does not ask what the neighbour heard; it fixes where the reading is taken. The business may well have been loud, and we are not asking you to find it was quiet. But the only reading in evidence was taken at the rear door, on Exhibit 3, not at the property line.

The answer has three steps, in this order:

  1. Answer. Respond to the question that was asked, directly, in the first sentence.
  2. Concede. Give up what is fair to give up. Here, that the business may well have been loud.
  3. Return. Bring it back to the finding, with a record reference.

Do not answer a different question, and do not promise to come to it later. The bench asked now because the point is bothering it now. When you are done, pick up where you left off. If the question took you past a point on your roadmap, say so and skip it.

The Reply: Only What Is New

The other side has argued. Now, if you are given one, comes reply. It is the part licensees prepare least and use worst, usually by delivering the opening again, louder.

Reply is short by design. The Court of Appeal for Ontario's Practice Direction Concerning Civil Appeals, for example, limits oral argument on panel motions to 15 minutes for the moving party, 10 minutes for the responding party and 5 minutes for reply. On appeals, the same practice direction says the court assigns time for each party's oral argument "including any time for reply", and that it expects the parties to adhere to their time assignments. Other courts and tribunals set their own practice, so check the one you are in.

What follows is our practice advice for any reply, not a rule of court:

  1. While the other side speaks, note only what is new: a point, an authority or a reading of the evidence you have not already answered.
  2. Strike anything you already covered. Arguing it again signals worry, not strength.
  3. Pick the one or two new points that touch your finding. Let the rest go.
  4. Answer each with a record reference, not an adjective.
  5. Finish by restating the finding in the words you opened with.
  6. Sit down before your time runs out.

In the hypothetical, suppose the regulator's representative argued that "rear" in the notes could include the property line. That is new. The reply answers it and nothing else:

One point in reply. My friend says "rear" could mean the property line. The note says more than "rear". It says "laneway, rear", and Exhibit 3 shows where in the laneway: beside the door. That is the only evidence of where the reading was taken. We ask you to find that it was not taken at the property line.

Six sentences. One new point answered, the record cited, the finding restated in the opening's words. Then sit down.

Questions Licensees Ask

What Is Oral Argument In Court?

Oral argument is the spoken part of advocacy, at the end of a hearing or on a motion or appeal, where each side tells the decision-maker what finding or order it wants and why the record and the law support it. It is not a reading of your written materials. It is an exchange with the bench, and the best of it answers the questions the decision-maker actually has.

What Is Argument In Court Called?

Usually submissions. You will hear oral submissions, closing submissions or simply argument, and on appeals, oral argument. The written version is often called a factum, the term the Court of Appeal's practice direction uses, and many tribunals simply ask for written submissions. Whatever the name, the job is the same: ask for a specific finding and show where the record supports it.

What Happens After Argument In Court?

The decision-maker either decides on the spot, often with brief oral reasons, or reserves the decision and releases reasons later, usually in writing. Either way, do not expect to add points once argument closes unless the decision-maker invites further submissions. That is why the last thing you say, in your submissions or your reply, should be the finding you need, stated plainly.

Practise Oral Argument In Court With A Coach

A sequence like this reads easily and falls apart the first time a bench interrupts. The way to hold it is to run it out loud in front of someone who will tell you where it broke. That is what the 2026 Legal Argument Bootcamp is built for. It is coach-driven: you work a scenario, develop your submission strategy and deliver your argument on camera, then get direct feedback on structure, persuasion and delivery. It is eligible for up to 3 Substantive Hours, and it is $250 + HST.

Every class is recorded, so you can join now and catch up on the recordings, or ask us about the next date. For everything else we teach, see our list of programs.