The client hands you an offence notice for driving while holding a hand-held device, and the first thing they say is that they were stopped at a light, or that the phone had fallen on the floor, or that it was only for a second. Every one of those explanations has already been tested in the Court of Appeal for Ontario, and most of them lost.

That does not make a handheld device charge undefendable. It makes it a charge you defend on the elements and the evidence, not on the story. This article sets out what the prosecution must prove under section 78.1 of the Highway Traffic Act, where the burden shifts to the defence, what a conviction costs, and how we would plan the cross-examination of the officer. It is a sample of how we teach provincial offences work: the statute first, then the cases, then the evidence, then the room.

The Handheld Device Charge Under Section 78.1, Read As Elements

Start with the words. Section 78.1(1) of the Highway Traffic Act provides that no person shall drive a motor vehicle on a highway while holding or using a hand-held wireless communication device or other prescribed device that is capable of receiving or transmitting telephone communications, electronic data, mail or text messages. Section 78.1(2) creates a parallel prohibition for a hand-held electronic entertainment device, or another prescribed device, the primary use of which is unrelated to the safe operation of the motor vehicle.

Broken into elements, the prosecution on a subsection (1) charge has to establish:

  1. The defendant was the person driving.
  2. The thing driven was a motor vehicle, which section 78.1(8) defines to include a street car, motorized snow vehicle, farm tractor, self-propelled implement of husbandry and road-building machine.
  3. The driving was on a highway.
  4. While driving, the defendant was holding or using the device.
  5. The device was a hand-held wireless communication device, or another prescribed device with the stated capability.

Write those five lines at the top of the file before you read the disclosure. Every piece of evidence you receive either proves one of them or it does not, and the gaps are where your trial lives. Most licensees who lose these files lose them because they argued the client's explanation instead of auditing the prosecution's proof, element by element.

Notice also what is not in the list. The section does not require proof that the defendant was distracted, that anyone was endangered, or that the device was in use for a call. "Holding" and "using" are alternatives. Proof of either is enough.

Holding Means In The Hand: What Kazemi Decided

The most common explanation clients offer is duration: it was only for a moment. In R. v. Kazemi, 2013 ONCA 585, the driver was stopped at a red light, picked up a phone that had fallen to the floor when she braked, and was seen with it in her hand. The appeal judge below had held that the section requires some sustained physical holding. The Court of Appeal disagreed.

Writing for the court, Goudge J.A. held that the ordinary meaning of holding a cell phone is having it in one's hand, and that nothing suggests a person must hold it for a sustained period. The court tied that reading to the purpose of the provision, road safety and the driver's undivided attention, and observed that a duration requirement would leave the uncertainty of how long holding must last and would create an enforcement problem. The conviction was restored.

Two practical points follow. First, a "momentary" defence on the meaning of holding is not available as an argument of law. Second, the facts in Kazemi included a stop at a red light, and the driver did not contest that she was driving at the time. The issue the court decided was holding, not driving. Keep those two questions separate when you read the disclosure, because they are separate elements.

What Kazemi does not do is relieve the prosecution of proving the holding. Whether the officer actually saw a device in the defendant's hand, rather than inferring it from posture, a glow, or a hand near the face, is still a question of evidence. That is where cross-examination earns its keep.

Using, And Whether The Device Has To Work: What Pizzurro Decided

The second common argument is about the device itself: there was no proof it was a working phone, or that it could send or receive anything. In R. v. Pizzurro, 2013 ONCA 584, released the same day as Kazemi, the appeal judge had made capability an essential element and dismissed the charge because the prosecutor had not proved it.

The Court of Appeal allowed the Crown's appeal. It read the capability words in section 78.1(1) as applying to prescribed devices, not to cell phones, and held that the section does not require proof that the cell phone held or used by a driver was capable of receiving or transmitting. Requiring that proof, the court said, would be unreasonable for enforcement and for prosecution, and inconsistent with the purpose the court had described in Kazemi.

The respondent in Pizzurro never disputed that what he held was a hand-held wireless communication device. That matters for your file. The decision removes the need to prove a cell phone worked; it does not remove the need to prove that the object was a cell phone or another device that falls within the section. If the officer's notes describe "a dark object" or "a device" without more, the identification of the object is a live question, and it is a question of fact for the trial.

The same discipline applies to a subsection (2) charge. An entertainment device charge is a different count with different wording. Read the charging document and confirm which subsection is alleged before you plan anything.

Driving, On A Highway: The Elements Clients Forget

Two elements are easy to skip because they seem obvious. The first is driving. The Act defines "driver" in section 1(1) as a person who drives a vehicle on a highway. Section 78.1(6) then sets out a statutory exception for a vehicle that is off the roadway or lawfully parked on the roadway, not in motion, and not impeding traffic. All three conditions must be met. A car stopped in a live lane at a red light does not meet them on the words of the section, and the facts of Kazemi are a reminder of how that tends to go.

The second is the highway. The Act defines "highway" to include a common and public highway, street, avenue, parkway, driveway, square, place, bridge, viaduct or trestle, any part of which is intended for or used by the general public for the passage of vehicles. In R. v. Hajivasilis, 2013 ONCA 27, a five-judge panel noted that the phrase about passage of vehicles limits the definition, and that most privately owned parking lots are not highways as the Act defines the term. The court also held that many provisions of the Act, especially offence-creating ones, are expressly limited to highways, while others are not.

Section 78.1(1) is one of the provisions that uses the word. So the location in the officer's notes matters. A drive-through lane, a private lot or a gas station apron is a factual question about public use for passage, and the prosecution has to prove the highway element like any other. Do not assume it; do not concede it without reading where the officer says the vehicle was.

Exemptions: Where The Burden Moves To The Defence

This is the part of the file where licensees most often get the law backwards. Section 78.1 contains several ways out: hands-free mode in subsection (3), the listed drivers and prescribed persons, devices and circumstances in subsection (4), a call to ambulance, police or fire emergency services in subsection (5), and the parked-off-the-roadway conditions in subsection (6).

The regulation fills in the prescribed parts. O. Reg. 366/09, Display Screens and Hand-Held Devices, lists categories of drivers who may hold or use particular devices while performing their duties, and section 14 permits a driver to press a button on a hand-held wireless communication device to make, answer or end a call if the device is placed securely in or mounted to the vehicle so that it does not move, and the driver can see it at a quick glance and reach it without adjusting their driving position.

Now the burden. Section 47(3) of the Provincial Offences Act places the burden of proving that an authorization, exception, exemption or qualification prescribed by law operates in favour of the defendant on the defendant. The prosecutor does not have to disprove it, except by way of rebuttal, whether or not the exception is set out in the information.

In practice, that means two things. If your theory is that the phone was mounted and the client only pressed a button, you need evidence of the mount, its position and the button press, and you need it to meet each condition in section 14. And if your theory is an emergency call, you need the call. An exemption you cannot prove is not a defence; it is a story. Build the evidence for it early, while it still exists.

What A Conviction Costs, And Why The Track Matters

Advise on exposure before you advise on strategy. Section 78.1(6.1) sets the fines: for a first offence, not less than $500 and not more than $1,000; for a first subsequent offence, not less than $500 and not more than $2,000; for a second or additional subsequent offence, not less than $500 and not more than $3,000. Section 78.1(6.2) requires the Registrar to suspend the driver's licence on conviction for three days for a first offence, seven days for a first subsequent offence, and 30 days for a second or additional subsequent offence. Under section 78.1(6.3), an offence committed more than five years after a previous conviction under the section is not a subsequent offence for those purposes.

The procedural track changes the picture. Section 12(1) of the Provincial Offences Act provides that where the penalty prescribed includes a fine of more than $1,000 and a proceeding is commenced under Part I, the offence is instead punishable by a fine of not more than the maximum prescribed or $1,000, whichever is less. Section 12(2)(a)(iii) keeps the consequences provided for under the Highway Traffic Act in place for a conviction in a proceeding started by offence notice. Read the charging document, confirm which Part the proceeding is under, and explain both the fine range and the licence consequences in that light. We walked through the track question in more detail in our piece on where provincial offences files are lost on procedure.

Clients often want to know about demerit points and insurance. Those consequences come from other instruments and from the insurer, not from section 78.1. Check them from the current source on the day rather than from memory, and say so in your advice.

Pending Amendments: Read e-Laws On The Day You Advise

As consolidated on e-Laws when we checked, section 78.1 carries notes for amendments enacted in 2026 (S.O. 2026, c. 7, Sched. 5) that come into force on a day to be named by proclamation. When in force, they would replace subsection (3) so that hands-free use is permitted only if the device's display screen is not showing entertainment, or text or images beyond what section 78 and the regulations permit. They would also add higher fine ranges and longer licence suspensions where the offence is committed by means of a commercial motor vehicle, and amend subsection (6.3) to match.

None of that is the law until it is proclaimed. But it is a reminder that the provision you learned is not always the provision in force on the offence date. Pull the section as it read on the date of the alleged offence, check the amendment notes, and keep a copy in the file. A defence built on an old version of subsection (3) is the kind of mistake that is entirely avoidable.

Working The Officer's Evidence: A Cross-Examination Plan

In most handheld files the prosecution's case is one officer's observation. Section 46 of the Provincial Offences Act gives the defendant the right to make full answer and defence and to cross-examine witnesses. Use it on the elements, not on the officer's character. Before trial, in our view, the file should contain the following, requested in writing as early as possible:

  • The certificate of offence or information, and the offence notice served.
  • The officer's notes in full, including any diagram, and the time the notes were made.
  • Any in-car or body-worn camera recording, or written confirmation that none exists.
  • The officer's position, distance, angle and lighting at the moment of observation.
  • The description of the device, the hand it was in, and how long it was observed.
  • Anything the client said at the roadside, and when it was noted.

Then build the cross one fact per question, each tied to an element. A sequence on the holding element might look like this:

Officer, you were in a marked cruiser in the lane to the left of my client's vehicle? You were looking through your passenger window and my client's driver's window? It was after sunset? Your notes describe "an object" in my client's right hand? Your notes do not record the colour of the object? Or its size? Or a screen? You did not seize the object? You did not ask to see it?

Each question carries one fact, and each fact goes to whether the officer actually saw a device in the hand, which is the issue Kazemi leaves open. That is the approach we teach in our article on one question, one fact, every time. Do not ask the last question that invites the officer to explain. Save the gap for submissions.

If the defence evidence puts forward a different account, for example that the object was a wallet or a toll transponder, put that account to the officer during cross-examination so the officer has the chance to respond. Then call the evidence that proves it.

Bring It Into The Room: Defending A Handheld Charge

Everything above is the reading. The skill is putting it together under pressure, on your feet in a provincial offences courtroom, in front of a justice of the peace. That is what our program 2026 Defending a Handheld Charge is built to do. Frank Alfano is one of the instructors, and the program takes licensees from the legislation and the case law, through the essential elements and the prosecution's burden, into disclosure, officer observations, cross-examination and a defence theory, and closes with a mock trial that shows the issues develop through testimony, cross-examination and submissions.

It is a single evening session, online, eligible for up to 3 Substantive Hours, at $100 + HST. The date and enrolment are on the program page, and every class is recorded. If the timing does not suit, see our full list of programs, including the Provincial Offences Bootcamp for licensees who want the whole Act from charge to appeal.

This article is general information for Ontario lawyers and paralegals. It is not legal advice on any matter, and it has not been reviewed as legal advice for any client. Check the legislation and the cases as they stand on the date of your offence before you rely on them.

Frequently asked questions

Is it still a handheld offence if I was stopped at a red light?

Usually, yes. The exception in section 78.1(6) only applies when the vehicle is off the roadway or lawfully parked, not in motion, and not impeding traffic, all at once. In R. v. Kazemi the driver was stopped at a red light, did not contest that she was driving, and the Court of Appeal restored her conviction for holding a phone she had just picked up.

Does holding the phone for one second count as holding it?

Yes. In R. v. Kazemi, 2013 ONCA 585, the Court of Appeal for Ontario held that holding a cell phone means having it in your hand and that there is no requirement to hold it for a sustained period. The prosecution still has to prove the officer actually saw the device in the driver's hand.

Does the prosecution have to prove the phone was working?

No, not for a cell phone. In R. v. Pizzurro, 2013 ONCA 584, the Court of Appeal held that the words about being capable of receiving or transmitting apply to prescribed devices, not to cell phones. The prosecution must still prove the object was a cell phone or another device covered by the section.

Who has to prove the phone was in hands-free mode or mounted?

The defence does. Section 47(3) of the Provincial Offences Act puts the burden of proving that an exception or exemption applies on the defendant, so a hands-free or mounted-device defence needs real evidence of the mount, its position and how the device was used, measured against section 78.1(3) and section 14 of O. Reg. 366/09.

What is the penalty for a first handheld device conviction in Ontario?

Section 78.1(6.1) of the Highway Traffic Act sets a fine of not less than $500 and not more than $1,000 for a first offence, and section 78.1(6.2) requires a three-day licence suspension on conviction. Higher ranges and longer suspensions apply to subsequent offences within five years, and the procedural track can affect the fine.

Does the handheld law apply in a parking lot?

It depends on whether the lot is a highway. Section 78.1(1) only applies to driving on a highway, and in R. v. Hajivasilis the Court of Appeal noted that most privately owned parking lots are not highways under the Act, so the location in the officer's notes is a question worth testing.

Sources